Yazılar

Indian Court Rejects X’s Challenge to Modi Government’s Content Removal Rules

An Indian court has dismissed X’s legal bid to overturn the country’s new content removal system, ruling that the social media platform—owned by Elon Musk—must comply with local laws despite its claims that the mechanism amounted to censorship.

The case centered on Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s tightened internet regulations introduced in 2023. The rules allow a wider range of government officials to issue takedown orders directly through a centralized government website launched in October.

X had argued the measures were unconstitutional and gave “every Tom, Dick, and Harry” the power to censor speech online. But Justice M. Nagaprasanna of Karnataka’s high court rejected the claim, stating: “Every platform that seeks to operate within the jurisdiction of our nation must accept that liberty is yoked with responsibility.”

The ruling follows months of legal battles between X and government lawyers. India’s government defended the system as a way to combat unlawful online content, misinformation, and material it says spreads hate and division, while ensuring greater accountability for platforms.

Officials also noted that other tech giants, including Meta and Google, support the government’s approach.

X, which has repeatedly clashed with authorities worldwide over compliance demands, now faces the possibility of appealing the decision to India’s Supreme Court.

French Lawmaker Seeks Criminal Probe Into TikTok Over Youth Safety

A French parliamentary committee examining the psychological impact of TikTok on minors has concluded that the platform endangers the health and lives of young users. On Thursday, committee chair Arthur Delaporte announced he had formally asked the Paris public prosecutor to open a criminal investigation into TikTok.

Allegations Against TikTok

Delaporte, a Socialist lawmaker, accused TikTok of:

  • Deliberately endangering minors’ health and lives.

  • Possible active complicity in exposing children to harmful content.

  • Perjury, alleging TikTok executives misled lawmakers during hearings.

“It seems to me that there are offences of a criminal nature,” Delaporte told franceinfo.

TikTok’s Response

A TikTok spokesperson rejected the findings, calling them “misleading” and saying lawmakers were unfairly making the company a scapegoat. TikTok insisted it enforces strict policies to protect teenagers and their families, including dedicated safety features.

Background

  • The committee was formed in March 2024 following a lawsuit by seven families, who claimed TikTok exposed their children to content encouraging suicide.

  • The final report recommended:

    • Ban on social media use for children under 15.

    • Nighttime curfew (10 p.m. to 8 a.m.) for users aged 15–18.

Wider Scrutiny

TikTok, like other platforms, faces global pressure over child safety. Several countries in Europe, as well as Australia, are weighing restrictions on underage social media use.

French President Emmanuel Macron in June voiced support for an EU-wide ban on social media for under-15s, citing youth safety concerns after a fatal school stabbing.

The decision now rests with the Paris prosecutor, who will determine whether to pursue a formal criminal probe.

Brazil’s Lula Announces Social Media Regulation Proposal Ready for Congress

Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva stated on Tuesday that a proposal to regulate social media platforms in Brazil is finalized and will be sent to Congress shortly.

KEY DETAILS

  • Lula told BandNews the proposal will be on his desk on Wednesday afternoon, enabling the government to forward it to lawmakers.

  • The initiative comes amid ongoing global discussions on digital regulation and content moderation.

TRADE AND DIPLOMACY CONTEXT

  • Earlier this month, U.S. President Donald Trump imposed 50% tariffs on Brazilian imports, citing “unfair trade practices” in digital trade and political tensions related to former President Jair Bolsonaro.

  • Lula expressed willingness to meet Trump, emphasizing a civilized dialogue between heads of state.

  • The Brazilian leader also confirmed sending an invitation to Trump for COP30, the global climate summit to be hosted in Brazil later this year.

  • Lula plans to call leaders from France, Germany, and the EU next week to discuss ongoing negotiations between the EU and the South American Mercosur bloc.

CONCLUSION
The proposal marks a significant step in Brazil’s efforts to regulate digital platforms, amid rising international attention on social media governance and trade relations with the United States.