Yazılar

Meta Urges California Attorney General to Block OpenAI’s For-Profit Conversion

/in /tarafından

Meta Platforms has called on California’s Attorney General Rob Bonta to intervene and prevent OpenAI from transitioning to a for-profit business model, according to a report by the Wall Street Journal on Friday. In a letter sent to the attorney general on Thursday, Meta expressed concerns that permitting OpenAI to become a for-profit company would create a troubling precedent.

Meta argued that such a move would allow startups to benefit from nonprofit status until they are ready to become profitable, thereby unfairly giving investors the advantages of both nonprofit tax benefits and for-profit gains. The letter cautioned that if OpenAI’s shift to a for-profit model were allowed, it could have “seismic implications” for Silicon Valley.

The company’s concerns center around the potential for nonprofit investors to receive the same financial benefits as traditional for-profit investors, while still enjoying the tax write-offs associated with nonprofit status. Meta has not yet responded to a request for comment, and the California Attorney General’s office was also silent on the issue.

This latest development comes after OpenAI, in its own legal battle, urged a federal judge in California to dismiss Elon Musk’s request to halt the conversion of the company to a for-profit entity. Musk, a former co-founder of OpenAI, filed a lawsuit in August, accusing the organization of prioritizing profit over public good in its AI development.

Musk, who launched his own AI company, xAI, has argued that OpenAI’s shift undermines its mission and represents a violation of contract agreements. In November, Musk sought a preliminary injunction in federal court to stop the transition.

OpenAI has responded by asserting that any restructuring would preserve the nonprofit’s continued existence and ensure it receives full value for its stake in the new for-profit entity, with a mission-driven focus. OpenAI’s chairman, Bret Taylor, emphasized that the nonprofit would continue to thrive and be able to pursue its goals.

In their letter, Meta also expressed support for Musk’s efforts to ensure public interests are considered in the decision to allow OpenAI to convert to a for-profit structure.

 

OpenAI Pushes Back Against Musk’s Attempt to Block For-Profit Conversion

/in /tarafından

OpenAI has asked a federal judge in California to reject Elon Musk’s attempt to block the company’s conversion to a for-profit entity. In a court filing on Friday, OpenAI argued that Musk, one of its co-founders, initially supported the move toward a for-profit structure before leaving the company due to disagreements over control and equity stake.

To bolster its case, OpenAI released a series of emails and text messages involving Musk, which it claims demonstrate that he was in favor of the company’s for-profit status. Musk, however, has since launched his own artificial intelligence firm, xAI, and filed a lawsuit against OpenAI in August, accusing the company of prioritizing profits over public benefit in its drive to advance AI.

Musk’s lawsuit also claims that OpenAI’s actions are anticompetitive, alleging that the company is working to monopolize the generative AI market and sideline rivals. He sought a preliminary injunction in November, asking U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers to block the conversion to a for-profit company, arguing that it violated contract provisions.

In response, OpenAI argued that Musk’s request is based on “unsupported allegations” and that he should focus on competing in the marketplace rather than through litigation. OpenAI also denied any conspiracy to restrain competition, emphasizing that it operates independently from Microsoft, which has heavily invested in the company.

Microsoft, in a separate filing, reaffirmed that it and OpenAI are independent entities that compete with each other and other companies, fueling innovation in the AI sector.

OpenAI, originally founded as a nonprofit in 2014, has become a major player in generative AI, with substantial backing from Microsoft. In October, OpenAI raised $6.6 billion in funding, boosting its valuation to $157 billion. Musk’s xAI, launched earlier this year, raised about $6 billion in equity financing.

The planned restructuring of OpenAI will transition it into a for-profit benefit corporation, with the nonprofit holding a minority stake in the new entity. Judge Rogers is scheduled to hear arguments for Musk’s injunction on January 14.