Internal communications revealed that major global advertising firms secretly coordinated to rig ad prices in India’s vast market, undermining competition and client choice.
In October 2023, Omnicom Media’s India CEO, Kartik Sharma, expressed frustration in a WhatsApp group after a rival agency attempted to poach a client by offering lower rates—violating an industry-wide agreement on pricing.
The WhatsApp group, formed in August 2023 and including top executives from WPP’s GroupM, Omnicom Media, IPG Mediabrands, Publicis, Havas Media, Japan’s Dentsu, and India’s Madison World, discussed coordinating pricing strategies and responses to clients. According to evidence reviewed by Reuters and obtained from India’s Competition Commission (CCI), the agencies agreed not to undercut each other, colluded with broadcasters to penalize non-compliant firms, and coordinated financial terms for at least four major Indian clients.
The cartel was facilitated by two industry bodies—the Advertising Agencies Association of India (AAAI) and the Indian Broadcasting & Digital Foundation (IBDF)—both led by senior executives from WPP Media India and Reliance-Disney respectively. The AAAI circulated guidelines requiring agencies to charge minimum commissions on digital and traditional ads and agreed with broadcasters not to offer unilateral discounts.
The CCI dossier revealed discussions about client pitches involving firms like Swiggy, Cipla, Meesho, and Kshema Insurance. For example, the AAAI arranged a Zoom call to unify the industry’s stance on rebates for Swiggy’s ad campaign. A Dentsu executive noted on WhatsApp that the agencies would retain 30% commission and pass back 70% to clients as rebates.
In August 2023, AAAI’s president urged broadcasters like Walt Disney to withhold business from agencies breaking the cartel agreements. Tensions rose when Omnicom Media learned that ITW Consulting had bypassed these pacts with a direct deal on Disney’s Hotstar streaming platform during the Cricket World Cup.
Despite these revelations, the foreign headquarters of the involved agencies have not confirmed awareness of the collusion. Dentsu India disclosed its involvement under the CCI’s leniency program aimed at reforming industry practices from within. Other agencies declined comment, and the regulator has yet to conclude its probe.
This investigation adds to ongoing scrutiny of ad agency practices globally, with similar probes underway in the U.S. following suspicions of anti-competitive behavior.